I can take the feedback, Also Marcus difference colors are just forms of his Divine Elemental Powers.
Character 1: 4/10 I swear I saw an identical armor/mech suit-looking outfit before. Looks like some general of sorts with a dumb look with bootleg Sasuke hair. Character 2: 8/10 I actually like this. He gives me that pre-final boss vibe of sorts with the scarf and all his clothes. Not the fake-edgy look either. 4.5/10? Can't fully see the bottom half, but it's fine Looks like a curious happy go lucky kid. Pretty simple overall. What're those shoes though? Are they supposed to glow in the dark? Why do they look like whole boots? Character 1: 7.5/10 That hair is so bright and blue, while the shirt looks so dark blue and black, and it's throwing me off more than it should. Although, I like the face/eye bandage and how he looks like an athlete. Makes it memorable for me. Character 2: 6/10 I like the grey scheme with the yellow eye color. Maybe a bit too monochrome. He feels kinda dated, but still cool. Character 1: 5.5/10 The white/purple hair and shoes are nice. Overall, he feels pretty straightforward and standard, which is still good. Character 2/Marcus: 3/10 on all of them That's a looooot of saturation on the hair and a near pitch-black vest. Probably doesn't help he looks like a mix of Auramaster face and Mali clothes. I like what you were doing with those Elemental Powers and changing colors accordingly though, so I'll give you that :).
8/10 This is female Makoto from Persona 3: Dancing Moon Night. Liked how he looks over there, and I like how she looks here. The emo hair and eyes match well with the clothes. Character 1: 2/10 This is 2007 alright. Slime shoes, alert eyes + metro hair. This kinda looks like my very first character...and Spritefan2 without the hat. Character 2: 4/10 It's fine. Kind of forgettable, but still not bad. I don't get his pants and shirt combination. Character 3: 5/10 The skull eyepatch is pretty cool. Everything else feels pretty typical or something I'm used to seeing. 3/10 Looks like the kind of guy who would AFK in Perion to flex his level. Either that or be a super typical warlord of an army. Character 1/N1N4: 9.5/10 Waifu swordsman cyborg now looks less cyborg and more waifu swordsman. Reminds me of Lyn from Fire Emblem, and I love her so much. Like the sprite style and really love the change with the hair and body to further emphasize the swordsman part of her. Character 2/Murderer: 8/10 Losing the shirt is better, and actually showing his muscles helps compliment the fierce, scary face. He looks like he'd be great at climbing things. Outfit 1/Normal: 8/10 Looks like a really good balance between the white and black/grey colors. The clothes and face go well together for me. Outfit 2/Fastfood Worker: 5/10 Spoiler: At least he's memorable I'm sorry, I at least know the context of what you were going for, but I just can't unsee this. Outfit 3/Prom/Business Suit 6/10 I don't think that bandana fits anymore, but hey, it's the signature look. You're missing the bowtie here. May as well be more formal. 3.5/10 Looks like a wanna-be edgy teenager. Born with some cursed eye and spikey hair wearing the good ol black hoodie and pants with chain. If it was like 2011-2012, he'd probably be higher. Character 1/Wendigo: 4/10 I dunno about those eyes. They are scary as hell, especially with the super bright pink hair. The outfit is ok though. Not sure if it fits, but it's alright. Character 2/Kitsune 5/10 for both. Definitely shows that she's a fox goddess. Not sure if the armor fits the whole fox schtick. I'm used to seeing Foxgirls in kimonos.
Here you go Shulke, Kimono as you ask, it really suits her, thank you for feedback. I will work on Otto later.
Ayyyy, you get a 0.5 extra credit bonus~ Character 1: 3/10 A 3/10 you ask and a 3/10 you shall get. Reminds me of that base character you'd see in Edelstein. Maybe different clothes, but sure reminds me of that. Hair makes it better though. Character 2: 4.5/10 Nice moustache, got that whole royal guard vibe of sorts. Maybe a bit too similar to that of a general, but that's fine. Character 1: No. Staring at him do 1 frame shaking hurts. Hold at L. (6/10, the cape is cool. Everything else is average. You've nerfed yourself for ditching the lightsaber) Character 2: 7/10 God damn that hair is so huge. That's the memorable part of the character but man, why is it so big? Looks like the thread slowed down a fair bit, so I'll start checking this much less frequently, or maybe drop it. Thank you to everybody to everybody who submitted a character! It was fun being able to see them and make a comment without being flamed back!